> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://magiccircle.email/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# LOVE KNOWS BETTER THAN ANYONE ELSE
- URL: https://magiccircle.email/leaks/love-knows-better/
- Published: 2026-11-15T16:19:08.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-15T16:19:08.000Z
- Author: Cynthia Clifford
- Tags: 🛠️ Construction Notes, leak

I am currently working on a series where I talk about my current experience of constructing faith in my life again. I wrote a note in the first part of this and will share it here as well, for context and to share my hope for these. I want to be sensitive that these topics bring up a lot for people, and though this is personal to me, I am also hoping that these will be helpful and bring a sense of relief to some of my readers.

Note from last post:

I am trying to write about my journey back to faith in real time, and hopefully someone can find these notes useful. I have decided to share it because 1) I want it to be public, and 2) I want it to be hopefully helpful. It's also on my mind all the time. To be clear, this journey is still new for me. Though I have a long history with Jesus and Christianity that I claim, it was only this year that I began to re-engage, and only a few months ago that it started becoming the centerpiece of my life again, after what I would say was four years of losing my faith very slowly and painfully. I know lots of my readers will have aversions toward and big feelings about Christianity, and I do too, and I am working through some of that. I hope you will see my heart, and that I am trying to detangle some of this for myself and have no interest in hurting anyone. So, if you'd rather not engage with this, please don't feel the need to read these. I also write lots of other things! And if you have any questions, please reach out to me about this. I don't have the answers (if that isn't already clear), but I am always willing to listen and take any feedback or considerations with sincerity.

—

I noted in the previous construction note that this process for me starts first and foremost with love. It is what led me back, it is what first made me interested in Jesus and a life following him, and it is what compels me more than anything else.

If you had asked me a year ago whether I would ever become a Christian again, I would have said no. It wasn't because I didn't want to—rather, every time I tried, I felt crazy and far from any type of faith. If I was being honest, I couldn't see it ever becoming real to me again, and I did try. I tried multiple times, even around October, this time last year, because I wanted it to fix my life. But when I went to try again, I had zero faith. I didn't believe in any of it at all, and it made me so angry. And that was the most devastating part. I couldn't tell if I had left God or if he had left me, or if it truly was all just a hoax. As someone who struggles with a fear of being abandoned and fear in general, I found it hard to see any possibility of faith. 

I must add some context here, before moving to New York, I was a pastor at a church that was very toxic. The head pastor, my then-boss, was a spiritually abusive man who manipulated scripture, spiritual things, and exploited the goodness of people to gain power. One of the fallouts of being in a spiritually abusive church for years is that you feel fucking crazy. The environment that seeemed safe and secure was deceitful, and all tangled up with the words of Jesus. A particular nasty recipe for someone, who already had mistrust issues. Uh-oh. 

At the beginning of the year, I started teaching a poetry workshop, and the students were the same age as the kids I had pastored at the church. We, of course, weren't talking about scripture but about poetry, which in the last few years has been the saving text of my life and is very spiritual. I left my first class and cried on the train ride home because it went well, but even more because it felt familiar.

Being a pastor was my first real "professional" dream as a teenager. I mean, I would tell people I wanted to be a doctor, and I wanted to go to college, but I really wanted to be a pastor. I remember being seventeen and telling my youth pastor, in tears and very anxious, that more than anything I wanted to be a pastor. Without missing a beat, he said, "You'd be an amazing pastor." His encouragement became a core memory for me. I loved the Bible, but I really loved people. I loved what the love of Jesus could do and bring out in others. It made my whole heart burn.

In Christianity, there is a lot of talk about *calling*. When I was a teenager in church, a lot of this was meshed with the job you would get, or with some weird capitalistic idea that what you do is who you are. But I think, at the heart of it, *calling* is what God has for someone to cultivate, or, to partner with and bring about something very very good.

I am NOT saying that I am called to be a teacher, and I am not saying that I am called to be a pastor. I don't think that's how it works. But what being a teacher that semester did was awaken something that had been dormant for years. It empowered me to do good to others again. In some ways, this must require an exercise of faith, because to do good in a role like teaching, I had to believe that poetry matters, that the students matter, what I do matters, and that what happens next will matter. 

On the first day of class, I told the students that we could create a space for creativity together in the middle of a dark time, one that we would all remember and it could be good. I told them I believed poetry had the power to cultivate and change the world around us, because it pushes us to be attentive and to have empathy.

I wasn't fully aware of it at the time, but I was starting to exercise a type of faith again. I believed in something good, and I believed I could do that good again. It brought me down to the basics of faith.

To ground this now, I have since decided to make faith a much more sought-after practice in my life. One of the most difficult parts is that, coming out of a very toxic religious environment, I am scared that I will be deceived and that my faith is going to trick me. 

Earlier this year, in tears, I told a pastor I trust very much, that my fear is that the walls are going to start melting again. I fear that what I thought was true really wasn't and isn't, and that I'll have to escape because it's melting and there is a fire. 

The way I understand faith right now is as a building block. [In my first construction note](https://magiccircle.email/leaks/basic-tool-for-building/), I said everything starts with love, and I think of love as the foundation. Faith is what gets built on top of it. 

Galatians 5:6 says the only thing that counts is "faith working through love." Faith doesn't work on its own. Rather, love is what makes it work, which is my safeguard. The church I left built its faith on power and fear, and you could see it in what it produced. When I'm scared I'm being deceived, I don't have to answer every doubt. I just have to check the foundation, is this producing love? If it isn't, it isn't what I'm building on.

In *Works of Love*, Kierkegaard says (and in my version I like that it’s all capitalized): 

**LOVE BELIEVES ALL THINGS—AND YET IS NEVER DECEIVED.**

 I like that it’s capitalized because it is victorious.

Take this—

“Since mistrust believes nothing at all, it does just the opposite of what love does.” Kierkegaard goes on to say that “mistrust says deception stretches unconditionally as far as love does, and they can imitate true love so strikingly that there is no absolute criterion of truth or of honesty and integrity,” then turns it to choice and agency (free will!) and reminds us of reality, “existence will test *you*, test your love or whether there is love in *you*. For this very reason, with the help of the understanding it presents you with truth and deception as two equal possibilities in contrast to each other, so that there must be a revelation of what is in *you*, since you judge, that is, since in judging you *choose*.”

His point here is that mistrust isn't the safe, neutral option it pretends to be. Mistrust is a belief, just a belief in the worst, and it’s a choice we can opt out of. Since I left that church, I've thought my suspicion was protecting me, but it was building something too, and what it built was a prison where nothing good could live or come to me. 

I think of [Anxiety from Inside Out, who is in one of her fear spirals.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZFww62w4Wc&ref=magiccircle.email) If we want to follow outcome of mistrust--this spiral is what mistrust does, it makes us hurtful to the people we love and to ourselves. We can rather trust that, the person who deceives love is the one who loses, and this doesn't mean we stop being wise. But, it does mean we stop letting fear be the foundation. 

Then there is Hebrews 11:1, "Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." The Greek word for *substance* means something akin to *what stands underneath.* Faith is the ground I stand on before I can see what's being built. Simone Weil wrote that the attention students practice is the same attention that prayer is made of. She believed that learning to really look at a poem or a problem or a person, and it trains the soul to look toward God. When I told my students that poetry makes us attentive, I was also describing my own way back. Paying attention was already a kind of faith. Faith works in tiny acts of trust and attention, built on love, slowly become something you can see, and what you can see holds up the next thing you can't see yet.

\*title from *Works of Love*

 In trust, 

just as matter cannot be added to or subtracted from the universe, or energy destroyed, so with something realJohn Ashbery, *The System*