Magic Circlethe circle that leaks.
Leak · 🎬 Movie Review · Tuesday, 10 November 2026 at 10:32 pm · 4 min read

Club Kid Shows Love’s Elasticity and Says It’s Safe to Grow Up

When I first moved to New York City in 2022, a friend told me the city was a jungle gym for adults. He was right. New York can feel like a constant spin, Chutes and Ladders with change around every corner and holes to fall through, everywhere—drinks after work, drinks after the drinks, another Partiful invite, friends who want you to meet more friends, 3 a.m. nights, brunch, networking, work this, work that. It’s part of the magic. The city is alive and always moving.

Earlier this year, exhausted and determined to make some serious changes, I said I felt like I’d been stuck in Neverland. A friend of mine likes to tell people to “grow up” when they’re upset about something silly. When I say pineapple on pizza is gross, she says, “Grow up.” The joke works because the complaint never matters. It’s majoring on the minors, giving your full attention to something that doesn’t deserve it.

It’s easy for New York to get away from me and this is how it goes, majoring on the minors and letting what matters slip. I turned 30 this year, and the truth is, I want to act my age. I want responsibility. I actually am proud of having a job and being a working artist (another post for another time). I don’t want to be out at 3 a.m. or too hungover to work out and take care of my body. So part of it is simple and intuitive. If I had more time, I would explain why this isn’t just social pressure, but I won’t get into that now. But it does go deeper than that. The word the New Testament usually uses for mature is teleios, which means complete or whole, something that has become what it was made to be. Paul prays that our love would grow so that we may be able to “discern what is best.” That’s the kind of growing up I want: becoming whole, learning to tell the major from the minor.

Tonight I saw Club Kid, Jordan Firstman’s new A24 film, and it devastated me. I was so wrecked that afterward I had a hard time talking to my friend about it—she mostly just got my tears and a thumbs up. I knew I needed to walk home alone and let it wash over me more.

Spoilers ahead!! Turn back now.

Firstman, who also wrote and directed the film, plays Peter (of course his name is Peter), a New York party promoter who runs a party with his best friend and business partner, Sophie (Cara Delevingne—who has a very silly American accent lol). The party is famous for its red rooms and its drugs. The film opens with Peter in his twenties, full throttle in the scene, then jumps ahead about ten years, and the lifestyle is cutting against him—the business is falling apart, his body isn’t recovering as well, the powder is getting out of hand, turning into a full-on addiction, and then Peter learns he has a ten-year-old son, Arlo (Reggie Absolom, who is incredible and so cute). And the movie throws us into watching Peter decide whether he’ll take responsibility and who he will become now.

About halfway through, I was nervous it was going to wrap up in a way I would have deeply disagreed with, but it truly doesn’t. The movie roots for Peter without letting him off the hook. He has been living a life with no order in it and very little love for himself. And he mismanages Arlo at first. He has no tools yet to handle such a change, and all his friends care about is staying out, the next bump, being young and free, making art, who is doing what and with whom, and now he has to decide who he’s going to become. In Mere Christianity, C.S. Lewis writes that every time you make a choice, you turn the central part of you into something a little different from what it was before. For ten years Peter’s choices have been making him smaller and smaller. And now they have to start making him into a father, a friend, a partner, a man of his word.

For me the whole film comes into focus when the social worker comes to take Arlo away and tells Peter it’s going to be a long journey from here on out. He has to commit to an entirely new life; he has to start from the ground up and face himself and reality, literally—going to school, working a shit job, starting self-help. James writes, “Let perseverance finish its work so that you may be mature and complete, not lacking anything.” Maturity is what perseverance builds over time. I love when we jump ahead in time, his stable partner asks how class was, and he says, it’s so boring. Yeah, he is doing the work.

In The Four Loves, C.S. Lewis says that “to love at all is to be vulnerable.” The alternative, he suggests, is to wrap your heart in “hobbies and little luxuries” and lock it away where it can’t be broken, until it becomes unbreakable. For years that was what the club was for Peter. What we see as an antidote to this shackled heart is Peter having his heart busted open by his son, whom he loves more than anything—and that is the magic of love’s elasticity: it has no bounds and has room for all kinds of magic and grace. And when yielded to, it leans a life towards maturity, luck (mercy), and becoming whole. His love for his son heals him.

What I loved most is the way love transforms him. And I loved that Peter enjoys his life with this elastic love at the very center. Peter playing piano with his son and singing with his stable-lover-boyfriend in the background at the table was pure joy and made me so emotional. We see Peter face his grief and how hard life really is, and the movie shows us facing it is worth more than running from it, the way I know it can go: a fourth Partiful party in one weekend, too drunk at 3 a.m., missing the wake-up alarm again, and no plans (I love when someone tells Peter, “You are going to become someone who plans for the future”). It shows us sowing and reaping and the time it takes. It shows us that having a vision for a type of life is living and self-love. As C.S. Lewis said, we are “far too easily pleased,” like a child who keeps making mud pies because he can’t imagine a holiday at the sea. Club Kid shows us the sea and says we belong there no matter where we were before.

Who would have thought my shrivel’d heart / Could have recover’d greennesse?George Herbert, “The Flower”

Cynthia

Notes on the circle

A magic circle is the people in it.

Draw with me. free.

Not sentSentReceived

No ads. No selling the list. No AI.