Mostly On Circles
Good morning!
How-do-you-do? I tip my hat to you, good readers from afar.
My name is Cynthia, and I am the lead magic person here at Magic Circle (and the only person at Magic Circle… for now).
Wherever you’re reading from: welcome, welcome. Everything wants our attention right now, and most of it is selling or telling something, so I don’t take it lightly that you’re spending a few minutes of your time here. I hope this adds something to your sparkly world. It means a lot to me when anyone reads what I write, and I hope you will consider writing back. Ideally, these letters start to become two-way streets.
What I want, if I’m being earnest (I am always being earnest), is for you to leave each of these magic circles holding something. Something to take, share, turn over, destroy, or forget, but just something (!!)
I used to run a Substack way back in the day. Back in the daaaay. It was 2023, which does feel like a lifetime ago. It was called Magic Circle! I quit on it early because I thought I couldn’t write in this form, and I let the miserable voice run the show, the one that asks, why would anyone want another Substack with another opinion? Blah blah blah.
Now I’m a good three years older and much wiser (honestly, these have been dog years), and I’m doing this because I want to, and because I think I might add a little hope or wonder to someone’s life. That feels like reason enough. Ah, growth...
From the start, Magic Circle was meant to be a small enclosure for reading, a place that holds you inside something easy and life-giving for a while.
What I didn’t know was the history of the name, and, much to my surprise, it fit so well it was almost embarrassing.
Don’t you love it when rabbit trails line up? It’s one of my favorite feelings—or phenomena? It’s a kind of grace, a feeling of favor: stumbling onto something and realizing it was basically made for you. It’s where we lose track of time. Rabbit trails that open onto better rabbit trails.
So. Into the circle.
It all gets mystical when you remember the world itself is one. And through folklore and faith, the circle keeps turning up as sacred ground: a line drawn on purpose, inside of which different rules apply. So we got—fairy rings, the circle of confusion, wedding bands, salt circles, ORCs, He-who-sits-enthroned-above-the-circle-of-the-earth, clocks, ***eyeballs*, belly buttons, Jericho power, “a glory,” and hell according to Dante.
***A brief note on eyeballs, because I can’t not—it is one of my least favorite words. It’s too nakedly what it is. The very word itself forces me to confront the fact that there’s a circle inside my eyelid, a circle I can never fully see, which I find unsettling. If you see me on the street, please don’t talk to me about eyeballs (the word), and please refer to your eyeball as just your eye. I have been asking friends their least favorite and favorite words, and moist is so back!
I am sharing the phrase magic circle with the Dutch historian Johan Huizinga, who argued that play happens inside a boundary where ordinary rules are suspended. Inside it, a game comes into being, and something like magic becomes possible. It’s both sacred and childlike, and it works when people make magic together. Hug.
Academics have, naturally, been fighting about this for years. There was an entire conference called Breaking the Magic Circle, devoted to whether play can ever really be separated from life, and one scholar called the whole discourse a magic circle jerk (but in Danish lol). I could also go into the people trying to build a Magic Circle City (which sounds like Meep City) and the urban planning of it all, but I’ll stay in my newsletter lane for now.
So let’s call it a temporary world, but I like to think of it as a foretaste of the kingdom.
Then there’s my fav, the Magic Circle of 1905, when a group of magicians met at a restaurant in Soho and took as their motto indocilis privata loqui, roughly “not apt to disclose secrets.” Or– keep mum. They also had a sick fucking magazine. They swore never to reveal how a trick was done, and they understood that secret as a way of keeping the art alive, and as loyalty to one another. Of course, some L0$er revealed the secrets via book tour. He was kicked out, of course. Let some things just have magic!!
We’re allowed to wonder and not know the mechanics of everything we experience and love. We’re allowed to simply imagine for a while. One of my favorite memories, etched into my being at this point, is from one of my oldest friends. I was about to google the answer to something we were wondering about, and he said, what if we just imagined it, or tried to figure out the answer between us? I think about this all the time. All that to say (and, to be honest, so much more could be said): this is the second beginning of Magic Circle, but I dropped the (!).
Here’s what I hope to try, all of it subject to change.
There will be leaks, going in and coming out. Yes, that means please send me things! I want to share YOUR opinions, taste, and art. Yes, you. There will be interviews, some advice, artists I can’t stop thinking about, and whatever is striking a chord with me that week. But mostly, I’m going to have some fucking fun and make some magic.
I won’t be using AI for my writing, apart from grammar and uploading to my website (and even then, I’d rather not). Mostly, it keeps me honest and human or whatever, you know the whole bit already. Beep boop beep. The robots are telling us how to beeeee(p).
Some magic I noticed this week
Philly
- General Philly vibe & Friends Bday!
I was in Philly this past weekend for my friend Meg’s 30th birthday. She just had translations published in Poetry magazine. If I didn’t live in New York, I would live in Philly, is what I keep saying now. There was a parking-lot art show selling merch and celebrating a crab restaurant that had been demolished, but the enthusiasm made it feel so built that it could have fooled me. Magic, eh.
2. Merlin
I went to my friend’s birthday as Merlin from The Sword in the Stone. To me he has major main-character energy (the theme). Some would say Arthur is the real hero, but I just wanted to wear a beard and carry a wand. A guy at the party came as Joffrey from GoT, so in some very bad alternate reality, Merlin got stuck with Joffrey. Eek!

3. The anarchist bookstore
I found the anarchist bookstore, and I loved it.



3.5. My personal computer now

4. Duchamp is @ Philly
Duchamp has inspired Magic Circle, and all my stuff—god, if I start writing about him I won’t stop. I now have two shirts with his name on them. And I want a Duchamp tattoo.

5. The baby painting
This baby painting at the Philadelphia Museum of Art. What is going on here, huh? It reminds me of some of the art I saw on the walls in Berlin!

NYC
6. Club Kid
I saw Club Kid and cried. It’s tender. Peter and Arlo’s relationship is one to shed water over. I wrote some thoughts here. Warning: pretty Christian!
7. Spencer & her Birthday
It was my good friend Spencer’s birthday, and we celebrated at a delicious, slightly strange steak-frites place. Afterward, I noticed something Spencer always does. In New York, someone usually approaches asking for money, often someone living on the street. Spencer tends to look them in the eye, give them a few dollars, and, more than that, give them her time. It moves me every time, and it’s a useful reminder that I am, in fact, never too busy to speak to someone living on the street, even in a city whose whole culture insists otherwise. HBD, legend.
8. Good news (?) rant
I received a lot of good news this week, and, to be honest, it made me pretty sad, and then I felt guilty for being sad. I suspect some of you know the feeling. I am grateful for every good thing that comes my way, and even this caveat is part of what I mean. Sometimes it just makes me lonely, and that’s fine too. One friend called it fear of success; another called it depression. Maybe. But I think it’s just living. When good news arrives, especially news with the force to change your life (which it often has), it’s daunting and exciting at once. And sometimes the thing we wanted so badly finally comes, and we realize we’re still the same person, and there’s still laundry to do and we still have to get up early and go to work. We expect the big boom bam, but really, we just keep moving along with our little tools. That’s okay. I think that's part of contentment. There’s a quiet societal pressure to expect good news, or any change, to deliver everything it seemed to promise the moment we heard it, and it rarely does, we have to walk out almost every gift that's given to us.
9. Espresso is worth every. penny.
The best purchase I have made this year is a good espresso machine. Yeah, I got one of those Breville $$$ ones. I would sell 1/2 of my clothes to keep it. I just cleaned and descaled mine, and having it back feels like my back has been realigned. It was looking a little scary there for a minute. But now look at that foam.

10. Poem
I have begun the EPIC task of ranking my top 100 poems, or what an old professor called island poems– 100 poems you’d take with you to a deserted island, but also ranked. The idea is how you rank them shows where your writing is wanting to go! Here is one of my top 100. (Note: it talks about suicide, which can be kind of heavy for 9 a.m., or whenever you find this.)
The Only Animal, by Franz Wright
I bid you adieu, have a stellar weekend,
Cynthia